It
would be good if Jewish created media was able to explore Nazism, a
massive force in shaping Jewish life and experience, without the
guarantee that other people would romanticize, get off on or excuse
the subjects of that exploration.
Tag: cw:
at what point in history do you think americans stopped having british accents
Actually, Americans still have the original British accent. We kept it over time and Britain didn’t. What we currently coin as a British accent developed in England during the 19th century among the upper class as a symbol of status. Historians often claim that Shakespeare sounds better in an American accent.
whAT THE FUCK
I’m too tired for this
Always add in the video that according to linguists, Native southern drawl is a slowed down British.
T’ be or not t’be, y’all.
Fun fact: Same thing happened with the French accent. French Canadians still have the original French accent from the 15th century.
Êt’e ou n’pô zêt’e, vous z’auts.
I’ve been trying to find this post for months. I’m freakishly obsessed with this and want the truth of what early colonists sounded like.
This is sometimes called the colonial lag hypothesis which is the idea that language evolves faster in the ‘original’ country compared to colonies – there are various explanations given for why this is and it’s sort of debatably a thing cause there’s also evidence against it. But for example ‘fall’ used to be used in British and American English but now we use ‘autumn’ but Americans still use ‘fall’ and stuff like that.
This doesn’t make American English the same as the ‘original English accent’ mostly because what are we counting as an original English accent? There isn’t really one. And American English has not evolved zero. But modern day American English would be closer to English spoken prior to colonisation of America at a given historical point than modern day British english.
This also happens in Spanish most notably would be the use of vosotros in Spain but not in Latin America and the converse survival of vos and associated verb forms in some some South American versions of Spanish (and in ladino) but not in all of them
Look while ‘nazis are used as an aesthetic generic evil’ is a valid critisism in many cases in media (because it’s antisemetic, antiroma and actively harmful to Jewish and Romani people to be clear, not in the odd ‘this is about me’ way non-roma gentiles seem to critisize this and deffinitly not because it’d be ‘unfair’ to nazis)
It doesn’t apply to things like hydra or the first order that are created by Jewish creators as explicit stand ins for nazism (or neonazism) given that Jewish people do absolutely not view nazis as a generic, aesthetic, impersonal or unreal evil even if you do
the flip side of
other people taking jewish created symbols of anti-nazism (like
captain america) and making them…well even just not a symbol of
that rather than explicitly a symbol of the opposite, is what marvel
has been doing for ages (and what fandom does) which is taking the
things jewish creators were using to symbolise nazism itself and
making them not about that – diluting it down to some kind of
ambiguity or just flat out erasing it whichever. That also damages that important anti-nazi message in the work you’re doing it to.
Its part of the same
thing. Portraying explicitly nazi-symbolising characters as not nazis
should never be a thing you consider okay and to see people protest
cap being hydra and then also do this shows very clearly it is not
the antisemitism that bothers you in this situation and that you just
flat out dont get it.
A History of Golems [wip]
It’s 1944. My grandmother is a short women with dark hair and a big nose. She works as a cook in an inn somewhere deep in the Third Reich. She tells the innkeeper the little girl who helps in the kitchen is her daughter. In the dining room men with red armbands drink to the war, calling the little girl to bring them more beer.
Its 2004. I read a storybook about the Golem of Prague in the public library. I wonder what words could have the power to make clay come alive, to make a shield that can move on its own. That week I notice for the first time the security guards outside my synagogue.
its 1961. My father is thirteen years old, an adult of the community now, so when they come down the Jewish street again with bricks and torches he helps my grandfather sweep up the broken glass.
It’s 1941. Two boys from an immigrant neighborhood get their art published and spread to the whole country. It shows a man wearing red white and blue, punching the leader of a country we were not at war with in the face. They get threats. The Golem they’ve made isn’t enough to protect their families, dying across the sea. Captain America is only made out of words.
It’s 2016. I am drinking with people I suppose are my friends. One draws a swastika on my arm. He apologizes almost immediately but my head is full of the sound of breaking glass. There is no holy word in my skull to give me strength.
It’s 1944. My grandmother and the girl are arrested. The officer who turned them in asks that they be sent to a labour camp together, not to the death camps. Every Nazi had one good Jew.
Its 2011 and my english class is reading ‘A Diary of Anne Frank’. A classmate tells me America saved the Jews. I tell him my grandfather fought in the war, I tell him about the Warsaw Uprising, the resistance in Vichy France, I tell him that the United States sent children back to Germany to die. He shrugs. “Jews can’t protect themselves.” I think about Golems again.
It’s 1945. My aunt is dead. My aunt was not the little girl with my grandmother. The little girl lived to her nineties. My aunt was four. My grandmother could not protect her daughter but she could try to protect this one life. But my grandmother was not a golem. Any holy words in her head were wiped away by the time the camp gates opened.
It’s 2016 and Captain America has been declared a Nazi by the company founded on an image of Adolf Hitler being punched in the face. I think about the Golem of Prague. In the stories after the worst of the pogroms ended the rabbis wiped the holy words off his forehead, took the scroll out of his mouth and put him to sleep wrapped in knowledge and the words of G-d. I wonder if after having the power inside of him, that clay vessel can ever again just be clay.
Marvel fandom should probably stop pretending that the growth in hydra/Nazi fans and fandom has nothing to do with marvel perceiving an increased demand for hydra related stories. If you aren’t actively critisizing that phenomenon or worse you are participating in it…then you going on about how marvel has wronged you personally rings a bit hollow.
This is the real world effect of it and should make it very very clear that romanticising and festishisism of Nazi characters Does not exist in its own fictional bubble.
Holocaust Remembrance Day (Yom HaShoah)
For more photos from the observation of Yom HaShoah, see the #YomHaShoah and #יוםהשואה hashtags and the a href=“Yad Vashem location page.
From sunset today to sunset tomorrow marks Yom HaShoah (יום השואה), a day to honor the memory of the six million Jews who died in the Holocaust.
Yom HaShoah is a national holiday in Israel, commemorated by speeches by the President and Prime Minister at Yad Vashem, the lighting of six torches by Holocaust survivors, prayers by the chief rabbis and two minutes of silence across the nation. While other countries have their own Holocaust days as well, many Jews around the world also observe the day at home and at important historical sites.
jewish person on tumbler dot com: “hey it freaks me out that so many people make excuses for nazi charcters and turn nazi imagery and fascism into a silly joke ex: hail hydra, the first order, etc, can tumblr fandom please stop for a second and think about what they’re doing and why it might be harmful”
5000 non-jewish, non-rromani tumbler dot com users screaming and falling over each other: “clearly you dont understand the nazi trope in popular culture. let me, someone who has no personal ties to the holocaust explain to you, a jewish person, why you’re overreacting and taking away my fun,”
Look. I’m a diaspora Jew. I don’t live in Israel. I have no family in Israel. I don’t contribute money to Israel. But when the UN Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization says that the Western Wall, the most sacred edifice in all of Judaism, is nothing but a hitching post, how, exactly, am I supposed to believe that the UN gives a half a damn about Jews or our history when they are actively trying to erase it? This isn’t an anti-Israel resolution, it’s an anti-Jew resolution.
I didn’t see that language (hitching post) used anywhere. And the issues surrounding the Western Wall have to do with the displacement of Muslim families that live in the area. Your faith doesn’t trump the right of others to live in their homes.
Do you want an article with the hitching post language? Here.
And erasing Jewish history is antisemitism no matter who lives there. Take your condescension and antisemitism elsewhere. You clearly understand nothing about Jewish history or identity. You do, however, feel somehow entitled to speak over those who do have that knowledge and identity so you can get high on the ecstasy of sanctimony. Well, you’re not getting a free pass. Not this time.
Okay, so from that and some research elsewhere I see that in Muslim tradition the wall is holy as well, due to the idea that Mohammed (pbuh) hitched his horse Buraq to a place on the wall, where a mosque now stands. The resolution that UNESCO passed states that Muslims should have a right to worship at the Western Wall, too, and criticizes Israel for not allowing this.
Do you think Muslims shouldn’t be allowed to worship at the Western Wall?
The Western Wall and the Al Aqsa Mosque are two separate structues in two separate places adjacent to each other. Praying at one does not preclude praying at the other. Acknowledging the Jewish origins of the Wall is simple acknowledgment of historical fact. The Wall predates Islam by 700 years. It was part of the Second Holy Temple in Jerusalem. Stop talking. You’re embarrassing yourself.
March 31st, 2016: 524th anniversary of the Alhambra Decree
A few days ago I published the Alhambra Decree. Today, March 31st, 2016, is the 524th anniversary of the Edict of the Expulsion of the Jews. The Edict was not revoked until December 16th, 1968.






